In 2021, the discovery of stress corrosion cracks in stainless steel lines forced France to shut down multiple nuclear power plants across the country, with a significant and long-term impact on the country’s energy supply and nuclear fleet.
As the demand for nuclear power grows across Canada, it’s up to researchers like Suraj Persaud, an associate professor of Materials Science and Engineering, to ensure current and future nuclear facilities are able to meet these demands.
“Corrosion ends up being quite a hot topic in the nuclear space because you need to make sure that plants remain operational,” says Persaud, an expert on corrosion and structural materials in nuclear energy systems.
“These plants need to last a long time with refurbishment and life extension out to possibly 100 years, so that’s where my research comes in.”
Persaud, the University Network of Excellence in Nuclear Engineering (UNENE) Research Chair in Corrosion Control and Materials Performance, has worked with Canadian Nuclear Laboratories, nuclear utilities and government agencies to ensure the long-term operation of the country’s nuclear industry.
Here, Persaud answers questions and shares insights about how corrosion impacts every aspect of the nuclear industry, how small modular reactors (SMR) factor into the equation, and how his research team is working to mitigate these risks.
Why is corrosion such a fundamental consideration to the nuclear industry?
Corrosion is a topic that impacts the entire lifespan of a nuclear reactor, from planning and construction to operation and waste management. As corrosion experts, we have our finger in every pot.
As we’ve seen in France, a failure in a nuclear power plant can cause huge issues — not just political ones, but safety concerns as well. It’s not like underground piping where you can easily replace components, so we need to ensure we’re building facilities that remain structurally sound for a long time. When we’re building a nuclear reactor, we have to ask questions like: What materials do we use to build the plant? What materials will provide the life needed in these environments?
Corrosion also impacts nuclear waste management. Briefly, Canada’s internationally supported plan is to place spent fuel into copper-coated steel canisters and deposited in a deep geological repository (DGR). These used fuel containers need to last up to a million years underground. This means that understanding and mitigating corrosion is a primary priority here as well.
What can lead to corrosion in a nuclear power plant in the first place?
A simple example is to think about your kettle. When you boil water, you deposit impurities in the water at the bottom of the kettle.
A similar principle applies to some corrosion in nuclear power plants. These systems run with high temperature water. The water is at approximately 300 degrees Celsius. Its chemistry is well controlled and the purity is extremely high, and materials used — such as stainless steels and nickel alloys — behave very well in these environments.
However, because you’re transferring heat energy within a large heat exchanger, you end up getting local boiling at certain surfaces, which can deposit impurities at the surface or within a restricted area. This can change the expected chemistry and you need to understand corrosion in these environments for materials selection and chemistry control.
Radiation can also have specific effects on nuclear materials, and how radiation and corrosion intersect is an important area of my work. This intersection creates even more complexities because you have to consider electrochemical corrosion alongside the impacts of radiation damage and radiolysis.
Corrosion also produces hydrogen, which for some materials in the core of a reactor can diffuse into metals and requires care to avoid hydrogen embrittlement.
You mentioned that corrosion covers the entire lifespan of the nuclear industry. What considerations do you have to keep in mind when it comes to planning?
The key factor when it comes to nuclear power plants is that these facilities were designed to operate for roughly 60 years. Now, with the growing demand for nuclear power, we want to extend the lifespan of these plants to up to 100 years. So we need to be sure that the components that are in these plants and have been exposed to these harsh environments are able to last another 20, 30, even 40 years. We have to ask ourselves what we need to replace and what we can keep.
Some components are also irreplaceable during refurbishment and research is needed on their extended performance.
And when it comes to nuclear waste management, we have to be certain about the material we’re using to ensure it maintains integrity over extremely long time scales.
With waste you’re not concerned about high water temperatures — you’re just dealing with mostly benign, 25 degrees Celsius groundwater. We know that copper does not corrode in pure water, but we have to consider what other species, such as sulphur, chloride or nitrate, can do. This also includes things like microbial corrosion or even the effects of extreme compression, due to glaciers in the next ice age!
The way to think about it is this: If you’re more corrosive for a short period of time, like in a nuclear power plant, you have to understand the corrosion process over a short-term test. But if you’re designing something that will be stored in a relatively benign environment and last an indefinite period of time, like with nuclear fuel waste, your work has to be incredibly thorough to evaluate extremely slow or negligible corrosion rates.
If corrosion is something that happens over an extended period of time, how do you study the corrosion process in materials?
All forms of corrosion happen due to processes that initiate at the atomic, nano– and micro scale. If we can understand how and why corrosion happens at those scales, then we can develop methods to stop those nano- and micro-scale processes from happening, maybe even prior to engineering-scale issues.
The Canadian Centre for Electron Microscopy here at McMaster is vital to this work. The equipment here helps us understand, at that atomic scale, corrosion in different materials, what we can do to mitigate it, and possible even develop predictive capabilities.
How does your work intersect with the future of the nuclear industry, and in particular small modular reactors (SMR)?
This is brand new territory when it comes to the nuclear industry. These plants are extremely rare, so you’re really trying to develop materials selection and chemistry control in the early stages of reactor development.
One example we recently did was working with MIT and Pennsylvania State University to understand how corrosion occurs in molten salt reactors (MSR). We’ve made significant strides in this area from a scientific perspective, but we’re really developing the theory from the ground up because the field of study is early stages compared to corrosion in existing water reactors.
We need to build Canadian expertise in this area. Even for water reactors, where there is a historical base of literature, there’s always more that we can do, and a big part of that involves training the next generation of nuclear scientists and engineers.